What to Do if the Tooth Fairy Forgets

We’ve all been there: life gets complicated, it’s bedtime, and it’s already late. The chaos of putting the pajamas on, brushing teeth, reading a story. And suddenly, the Tooth Fairy forgets and doesn’t make her visit. So, if you’re a parent who feels identified, welcome! For sure, 90% of parents have suffered this kind of guilt, so take a deep breath. You’re not alone, and there are plenty of ways to keep the magic alive. A slip-up like this can be an opportunity for more Tooth Fairy fun! Here’s a guide to help you navigate this situation with ease and creativity.

If Tooth Fairy Forgets: Creative Solutions for Parents

1. Blame It on the Tooth Fairy’s Busy Schedule

The Tooth Fairy is incredibly busy with her nightly rounds! Imagine going to pick up all the lost teeth in one night!
Take advantage of this situation and use it as a learning opportunity. Share with your child that sometimes, when there are so many teeth to collect around the world, the Tooth Fairy might need an extra day to swing by. Time to be patient. You can even suggest leaving the tooth under the pillow again for her to find.

2. Write a Magical Note

If the Tooth Fairy “forgot,” a note is a quick and easy way to explain her absence. Create a tiny, glittery letter on her behalf saying something like:
“Dear [Your Child’s Name],
Oh no! I flew by your house last night, but you were sleeping so soundly, I didn’t want to wake you up. I promise that I’ll be back tonight to pick up your tooth and leave a special surprise for you. Thank you for being patient!
Love,
The Tooth Fairy.”
For sure, this explanation adds an extra layer of enchantment to the experience.

3. Make It Extra Special the Next Day

Turn the delay into an opportunity for the Tooth Fairy to leave an “extra-special” gift. Maybe it’s a little more money, a shiny trinket, or even a sprinkling of “fairy dust” (glitter) around the pillow. If you have one of our enchanted Tooth Fairy sets, this is a perfect time to bring out the magic envelope or Tooth Fairy door!

4. Add a Touch of Humor

Children love whimsical stories, so a funny excuse might be all it takes to smooth things over. You could say:
“I heard the Tooth Fairy got caught in a traffic jam of butterflies last night!”
Or,
“It looks like she had to take an extra nap after flying all night.”
A good laugh can make the situation feel lighthearted and fun.

5. Create a New Tradition

If forgetting becomes a recurring issue (no judgment at all—parenting is hard!), you can make it part of your family’s Tooth Fairy tradition. For example, explain that the Tooth Fairy sometimes leaves “magic tokens” a day late because she wants to be sure the tooth is truly ready for her collection. This reframes the situation as something unique and special rather than a mistake.

6. Set a Reminder for Next Time

Forgetting once is an opportunity for creative problem-solving. Forgetting twice? Let’s avoid that! Set an alarm on your phone labeled “Tooth Fairy Time” to remind you to make the swap before bedtime. Better yet, prepare the Tooth Fairy goodies as soon as you notice the tooth is loose—then you’ll be ready to go when the big moment arrives. Making life easier is a good trick.

7. Keep the Magic Alive after Tooth Fairy Forgets

Above all, remember that the magic of the Tooth Fairy is about the joy and wonder it brings to your child. Small missteps don’t have to ruin the whole experience. Without a doubt, with a little creativity and love, you can turn any situation into a memorable and magical moment.

After the Tooth Fairy forgets, it’s only the start stage

In conclusion, the most important thing is to know that the magic depends on you. As parents, we can make it happen no matter what. Certainly, being late one day or one week because we were on vacation, the kids trust us, so if we wanted to make them believe, it would happen.